Working with a nanny agency

The agency sent nanny candidates. How do you choose?

You’ve paid a registration fee, the agency has sent two or three résumés, and every candidate looks qualified. Now the hard part is yours: deciding which person fits your child.

I’m Tammy Gold, a licensed clinical social worker and the author of Secrets of the Nanny Whisperer (Penguin). I work beside families and their agencies as a neutral second set of eyes and ears.

Tammy Gold, LCSWSecrets of the Nanny Whisperer by Tammy Gold, published by Penguin
By Tammy Gold, LCSW
Author of Secrets of the Nanny Whisperer (Penguin)
Tammy Gold, LCSW, MSW
Columbia University
Nearly 20 years helping families hire nannies

Hiring a nanny is one of the most important decisions you’ll make for your children. You don’t have to make it alone.

Spend 60 minutes by video with Tammy Gold, LCSW, author of Secrets of the Nanny Whisperer (Penguin). $189.

Book an hour with Tammy: $189 →
As seen inTODAYGood Morning AmericaCBSThe New York TimesThe Wall Street JournalTIMEWatch the reel →

What the agency has done, and what it hasn’t

A good nanny agency or household staffing firm has sourced candidates, confirmed work history and run initial screening. That saves you real time. What an agency can’t do is know your child the way you do, or tell you which of three qualified people will fit your family’s temperament and routines.

The agency is also paid when a placement happens. Most are ethical about it, but the incentive is to place, and yours is to match. Those aren’t always the same thing.

How to compare the candidates

  1. 01Go back to your job description
    Rank your musts, pluses and deal-breakers before you meet anyone, so you compare candidates to the job and not to each other.
  2. 02Interview each one the same way
    Use the same core questions, especially scenarios, so answers can be compared. 45 nanny interview questions
  3. 03Make one reference call yourself
    Even when the agency has checked references, one call of your own tells you about fit. Questions to ask nanny references
  4. 04Write down impressions the same day
    Separately from your partner, then compare.
  5. 05Trial your top choice before you commit
    Ask the agency how paid trial days work and when the placement fee is due. Nanny trial day
A SECOND SET OF EYES AND EARS

Want a neutral read on the candidates?

One call can make all the difference. Tammy has no affiliation with any agency or staffing firm and earns nothing from which candidate you choose. $189 for 60 minutes.

Book an hour with Tammy: $189 →

When none of the candidates feels right

It’s fine to say no to all of them. Tell the agency specifically what was missing, in terms of your child’s needs, and ask for more candidates. A vague “not quite right” gets you more of the same.

If you feel pressured to decide quickly because a candidate has “other offers,” slow down. A strong candidate who is right for you will do a trial day.

TWO WAYS TO USE YOUR HOUR

One call can make all the difference

Tammy does it with you, by video

Tammy joins your video interviews with the agency’s candidates, or reviews your shortlist with you, and tells you what she sees in each one for your child.

Tammy coaches you to do it yourself

Tammy helps you build a simple scorecard from your job description and shows you how to run the interviews and reference calls yourself.

Book an hour with Tammy: $189 →

Tammy Gold, LCSW, licensed clinical social workerSecrets of the Nanny Whisperer by Tammy Gold, published by Penguin
FROM THE AUTHOR OF SECRETS OF THE NANNY WHISPERER

Nearly 20 years helping families hire, onboard and manage nannies

Tammy Gold, LCSW, spent years matching families with nannies before writing Secrets of the Nanny Whisperer (Penguin). Today she works beside families, and their agencies, as a neutral expert: defining the job, interviewing candidates, checking references and setting up the first 30 days. She is not a placement agency and earns nothing from who you hire.

Book an hour with Tammy: $189 →  Press and media

Working with a nanny agency?

Keep your agency and add a neutral expert. Tammy has no stake in which candidate you choose, so her read is only about fit for your child.

THE AGENCY SENT CANDIDATES
How to choose between them
BEFORE YOU SAY YES
A second opinion on the placement
AFTER SHE STARTS
Onboarding an agency-placed nanny
INSIDE THE GUARANTEE WINDOW
Is this placement working?

Nanny agencies by city

Using a nanny agency in your city? Pay, overtime and written-agreement rules differ by state and city. Each guide covers the local rules and the questions to ask a local agency.

Nanny agency New YorkNanny agency Los AngelesNanny agency San FranciscoNanny agency ChicagoNanny agency BostonNanny agency Washington, DCNanny agency SeattleNanny agency MiamiNanny agency Orange CountyNanny agency San DiegoNanny agency WestchesterNanny agency Fairfield County

Sessions with Tammy are by video, so she works with families in every state. High-end household? See New York and Los Angeles.

Questions parents ask me

How many candidates should a nanny agency send?

It varies, but two to four well-matched candidates is common. Quality of match matters more than the number.

Should I still check references if the agency did?

Many families make one or two calls of their own. The agency checks for red flags; you’re checking for fit with your child.

Can I ask for a trial day with an agency candidate?

Yes. Ask the agency how trials work, who pays the nanny for the day, and when the placement fee becomes due.

What if I don’t like any of the candidates?

Say so, and be specific about what was missing. A good agency will keep searching.

Does Tammy work with my agency?

Tammy works for you. She has no affiliation with any agency, so her advice is only about fit. Many families keep their agency and add an hour with Tammy.

What does it cost?

A 60-minute video session is $189.

Map Before You Act™

Getting expert help to hire a nanny can be one of the most important things you do for yourself and your children. Book a call today.

One hour, by video, with the licensed clinical social worker who wrote the Penguin book on hiring a nanny.

ONE SESSION · 60 MINUTES

An hour with Tammy

Interviews, reference calls, trial-day planning and debriefs, the work agreement and onboarding. Your nanny or candidate can join. $189.

Book a call today: $189 →
ONGOING · MONTHLY

Childcare Expert Access

Want support beyond the hire? A 45-minute call every month, for as long as your child is in care. $150 a month.

See how it works →
FREE

The Nanny Hiring Kit

Screening call, reference questions, interview and trial-day checklist.

Download free ↓

Or text (818) 308-1358 · info@caremapmethod.com

Tammy provides expert guidance and coaching; this is not therapy. She is not a placement agency and does not run background checks. Hiring decisions remain your family’s.

More

A second opinion before you say yesQuestions to ask a nanny agencyNanny agency feesBook Tammy for your interview
THE COMPLETE NANNY HIRING GUIDE

Every step, in order

  1. 01How to hire a nanny (start here)
  2. 02Nanny job description
  3. 03First time hiring a nanny
  4. 04What to look for in a nanny
  5. 05How to find a good nanny
  6. 06Using a nanny agency
  7. 07Nanny screening process
  8. 08Nanny phone interview questions
  9. 09Nanny reference check questions
  10. 10Nanny interview questions
  11. 11How to interview a nanny
  12. 12Nanny interview red flags
  13. 13Nanny background check
  14. 14Nanny trial day
  15. 15Nanny contract
  16. 16Nanny onboarding: first 30 days
  17. 17How to manage a nanny
  18. 18Nanny cams & trust
  19. 19Nanny hiring consultant
  20. 20Nanny consultant Los Angeles

Work with Tammy on any step: interviews · reference calls · trial days · work agreement · all hiring help